The Wisconsin Democratic Primary Ranked-Choice Voting Experiment

With this big-field Democratic primary, we are wondering how this race might look in a different voting system. So, we're inviting you to participate in a special ranked-choice voting experiment.

Jul 07, 2026

The Recombobulation Area is a ~~19-time~~ 21-TIME! Milwaukee Press Club award-winning opinion column and online publication founded by Milwaukee journalist Dan Shafer.

The Democratic primary field of seven candidates at The Recombobulation Area and Main Street Action’s candidate forum in Jan. 2026. The field has since been narrowed to six candidates, with Missy Hughes dropping out in June. Photo by Jennie Brand.

Wisconsin’s partisan primary is on Aug. 11. The highlight item in this primary is, of course, the Democratic primary in the race for governor.

Polling on this race has been remarkably sparse. Context about who might be in the lead, or who might be in contention, hasn’t been easy to come by. And given the size of the field, it’s likely that whoever ends up winning will do so with a plurality — and not a 50%-plus-one majority — of votes.

But what if we thought about this race differently?

Ranked-choice voting is a system that has been growing in popularity, with more and more elections turning to this electoral system. The most obvious example in recent years has been in the 2025 mayoral election in New York City, where Zohran Mamdani emerged from the field to eventually win the race for mayor. Mayoral races here in the Midwest, too, have included ranked-choice voting — Minneapolis and St. Paul now use the practice, and several communities in Illinois and Michigan are also exploring plans to use ranked-choice voting.

We’ve seen this concept emerge in Wisconsin, too — to a certain degree. While some Republicans have opposed the concept, even pushing a constitutional amendment that would outlaw the practice in the state, others in the GOP have been more open to it. Earlier this year, Democratic legislators Mark Spreitzer and Clinton Anderson introduced a proposal on ranked-choice voting in Wisconsin. Last year, the Democratic Party of Wisconsin selected its next chair in Devin Remiker with a ranked-choice voting process among convention delegates.

We want to know how this system might work in the Democratic primary in the race for governor.

Given that this is a fairly large field, with six candidates competing to be the Democratic nominee, this is the perfect type of race to test how ranked-choice voting might work in such a race.

So, let’s try an experiment. We are inviting you to participate in a ranked-choice voting experiment for the Democratic primary for governor. At the link below, we would like for you to rank the six candidates, beginning with your first choice. You may rank all six, but that is not required.

We are hoping that several hundred people of our more than 10,000 subscribers will participate in this experiment in order to gain a sample size large enough to produce a meaningful result.

To help with this, The Recombobulation Area is working with @John D. Johnson, research fellow at Marquette University, to conduct this experiment. Johnson has experience working with the Marquette University Law School Poll, and he will help analyze the data to ensure it’s not being manipulated and to ensure it’s an accurate reflection of what people participating in this experiment are expressing in their RCV ballots. (He also has a Substack called “Blue Book” that you should subscribe to here.)

To be sure, though, this is not a purely scientific polling process. This is an experimental poll of readers of The Recombobulation Area, so the sample set is likely to skew toward higher-engagement voters (you know, folks who might subscribe to a Substack newsletter on Wisconsin politics), and may oversample respondents from Milwaukee and southeastern Wisconsin, where this publication is based.

It’s important to note that this will not reflect what any formal, professional, scientific polling might illustrate. The next Marquette University Law School Poll is scheduled for July 22, and that gold standard poll will offer a much better view of where voters stand on the race. This ranked-choice voting experiment is simply to give another view of how this primary might look if conducted in a different type of voting system.

So, here’s how this will work. Voting will begin when this newsletter is sent on Tuesday, July 7. Your ballot for this experiment will look like this:

This form — your “ballot” — will be up for a full week, with voting scheduled to close at noon on Tuesday, July 14.

At that point, Johnson and I will break down the data, and will then publish results and analysis of this experiment.

The process will work like this: If a candidate does not win an outright majority of first-preference votes, the candidate with the lowest number of first-preference votes will be eliminated, going to another round of tallying. In that next round, the second-preference votes of the eliminated candidate will be counted as first-preference votes, and on in subsequent rounds until a candidate has more than 50% of the vote and would be declared the winner.

VOTE HERE.

At the link above, you’ll find the ballot for The Wisconsin Democratic Primary Ranked-Choice Voting Experiment.

Please fill this out one (1) time.

We look forward to seeing this experiment unfold.

ICYMI: We shared some news about the state of our publication, and now that we’re back to being 100% independent, we’re offering subscriptions for 50% off.

Details here: